News 
 Local News 
 News 
 Entertainment 
 Bunfight over grocery prices 

Bunfight over grocery prices

19 Nov, 2009 04:00 AM
A REPORT suggesting that Australia has the fastest rising food prices in the industrialised world did not surprise southern Sydney's independent retailers and consumers.

The report by University of NSW Professor Frank Zumbo, based on OECD statistics, found that despite historically low inflation, Australia's food prices had risen by more than 40 per cent in the past decade.

IAG Bexley owner Jag Rawat said the price rises were caused by factors including the market power of Coles and Woolworths, proposed new planning laws and unscrupulous retailers.

Mr Rawat, 45, made available to the Leadera copy of a independently commissioned report on growth and competition in retail planning.

The Wakefield Planning Report said the concentration of major retailers was more than 50 per cent in most food sectors. "Work in the UK suggests that a market dominance above 25 per cent would normally be sufficient to raise potential concerns,'' the report said.

Mr Rawat, who has a masters of business administration from the US, said when he bought the IAG Bexley store in August it was run down. He has since been building it up.

"Despite the pressures of a young family, I still manage to go the markets to source the freshest and best value produce,'' he said.

"We don't sit in an ivory tower with teams of buyers manipulating prices.

"For example, the majors source fruit from overseas which does nothing to boost the Australian economy.''

Mr Rawat pointed to the Federal Government's failed Grocery Choice website as proof the public interest was being short-changed and that flaws in proposed changes to NSW planning policy could see the majors compete with small independent grocers in smaller centres.

"If you look at it on a square metre of floor-space basis, we employ a lot more people than Coles or Woolies - on average twice as many people per dollar spent,'' he said.

"This will change if the NSW Government has its way.''

Frank Ventra, manager of Freshworld Sylvania, said buying from the markets, bulk buying and savvy consumers kept his business competitive.

"[Major retailers] often send people in here to check out our prices,'' he said.

"But we don't go near them.

"We maintain the best prices and stick to what locals want, quality Australian produce.''

Cathy Hannah, 25, from Sutherland, said she compared quality and price when doing the family shopping.

"The big guys have produce from around the world and the prices yo-yo,'' she said. "It's becoming increasingly hard to balance your budget but no one seems game to stop Coles and Woolies.''

Disaster recipe?

SMALL retailers say changes to planning laws may be the final nail in their coffin.

The NSW Department of Planning's draft Centres Policy states it aims to "create a network of vital and vibrant centres that cater for the needs of business and are places where individuals and families want to live, work and shop'' by freeing up planning controls on retail development.

Jag Rawat, from IAG Bexley, said the policy would be the death knell for competition as it would allow Coles and Woolworths to open stores on the same scale as IAG.

"Once they've done this and destroyed competition they will charge what they like,'' he said.

Mr Rawat said the policy had no regard for existing retailers, would result in the oversupply of retail space and would mirror the US experience whereby retailers like Walmart had the market power to crush competition.

Click on the comment link below to share your thoughts on grocery prices in Sydney.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
a great story, something that affects everyone. great local angle, well done leader!
Posted by Jenny J, 19/11/2009 7:28:51 PM
This article highlights the little known point about changes to planning laws, not enough has been written about that in other press. If these changes come to pass coles and woolworths will crush all opposition.
Posted by Laurent_09, 19/11/2009 11:36:12 PM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Under seige: Jag Rawat, from IAG Bexley, is battling to keep prices low. Picture: Elliott Housego
Under seige: Jag Rawat, from IAG Bexley, is battling to keep prices low. Picture: Elliott Housego
Fresh is best: Frank Ventra from Freshworld Sylvania says consumers are the best judges. Picture: Carlos Furtado
Fresh is best: Frank Ventra from Freshworld Sylvania says consumers are the best judges. Picture: Carlos Furtado
Related Coverage
POLL
Q: Are grocery prices in Sydney too high?

Yes
(94.4%)

No
(5.6%)

Total Votes: 107
Poll Date: 11 November, 2009

Most popular articles

click here
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...