The controversy over lifting-tackles continues to rage around the tragic three-man tackle last month that left Newcastle's Alex McKinnon with serious spinal damage.
As I examined a photo in the book Rugby League — 100 Years in Photos, I couldn't help thinking: the more things change, the more they stay the same.
Two 1960s players were Brian "Poppa" Clay, St George lock-forward, five-eighth and devastating tackler, and South Sydney's legendary giant second-rower Bob McCarthy.
Although McCarthy was described as having the frame of a giant and the pace of a back, it didn't worry Poppa — he was renowned for his pile-driving technique — now known as the spear tackle — irrespective of the shape and size of his victim.
What has stayed the same is the pile-driving tackle; what has changed is that one tackler is often being assisted by at least another two.
Perhaps we should visit the past and allow only one player to effect a tackle; as long as it's not Poppa.
Paul Hunt, Engadine
Editor's note:
Do you have concerns about tackling in NRL games?
